I'm not sure if simply changing the file type and creator codes will work. You actually need to re-export the image. Preview in OS X and Picture Viewer for OS 9 will do that. I am not sure if you need a Quicktime Pro key do do it though.
Graphic Converter is actually a great tool for stuff like that, and cheaper than Photoshop by about $500
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ac8d7/ac8d79adcc9a7d382ce36d7a7667204e68996c9d" alt=""
.