Author Topic: And you wonder why Linux is not Mainstream Like Windows is?  (Read 2460 times)

willysnout

  • Member
  • **
  • Posts: 31
  • Kudos: 0
And you wonder why Linux is not Mainstream Like Windows is?
« Reply #15 on: 6 August 2002, 19:49 »
quote:
Originally posted by VoidMain:
Linux was written by people just like you.


Not quite!

 
quote:
A lot of software was written by people just like you who were frustrated that there was no software that would do exactly as they wanted, or it was too expensive. So they decided to do something about it, and wrote their own, and then shared the source code with everyone else so they had a chance to make their own improvements, for free, no charge, no questions asked. Personally, I think that people who are that generous are just plain cool, and I will support them in any way I can, and I won't make demands of them.


I can sympathize with your perspective, and in some ways I quite agree. Still, though, I'm willing to pay for something that works well and frees me to do the stuff that I really want to do. This should not brand me an "idiot."

quote:
I don't know if you have tried Linux but I believe there are several distributions of Linux that are much easier to install than Windows. I also believe that they are just as easy to use as Windows. And I believe they all work much more reliably than Windows.



The following is a serious, good-faith question: Can you recommend the least painful way for a non-specialist like myself, who doesn't want to become a specialist but who just wants to "drive the car," to check this out?

I'll genuinely and sincerely thank you for a real answer to my question. I am interested. Maybe there's a book out there? I only want to know what I really need to know, or to put it differently, I want to start swimming in the shallow end of the pool.

All of this stuff might be second nature to you, but not to most people and that includes me. I have specialized knowledge in certain areas but not computers.

quote:
I see the big issue right now is not ease of use, but off the shelf software such as games. There is no doubt that there are more games for Windows out there.



I don't care about games. I want an office suite that will be able to read documents and spreadsheets and powerpoints created in MS Office 2000 and Office 95. I'm not a "power user." Those documents are not complicated.

Linux needs to be able to run Quicken. I need a scheduling and synchronization program that will work with my Palm Pilot. I've got software like Black Ice firewall, McAfee Virus Scan, and Turbo Tax. Will Linux run these things?

quote:
And Linux will run a small percentage of those Windows programs, it certainly wont run them all. And usually the Windows programs will not run as good as they do in Windows. But hey, they are Windows programs, not Linux programs. Windows can not run *anything other than* Windows programs. Now if all of the off the shelf application developers will sell a copy of their software written for Linux as well as for Windows I believe Windows will die quickly. It's a chicken/egg type of issue though. Developers will not develop for Linux because of the small percentage of installed desktops, yet it is difficult to increase the percentage of installed desktops without the applications. But I believe it is coming, not as fast as I would like, but it's coming.



Maybe given my level of involvement, it's best for me to wait a couple years. That's my inclination given the situation you describe.

quote:
I will correct you. Neither Sun nor Oracle are Linux "leaders". In fact GNU/Linux is actually a direct threat to Sun's business (the Solaris operating system). Now what they both have realized is that if they want to survive they are going to have to jump on the Linux band wagon.

No, RedHat is not from Silicon Valley. They are from Raleigh, North Carolina. In fact they really don't have much to do with the development of GNU/Linux, but they have a nice way of tying all of the pieces together (GNU software, Linux kernel, the KDE software, and much more open source software) into an easy to install and use operating system.

They also provide support which is primarily what you are paying for when you purchase the boxed set of RedHat (along with manuals). RedHat also makes revenue from training and certification programs. You have always been able to download the CD images from RedHat for free if you wish. Also, RedHat was originally (and still is) put together more with servers in mind. But I (and many others) find it to be a great desktop operating system. In fact I just read where RedHat may now be changing that thinking (or enhancing it) to take desktop systems more seriously.

Having said that, RedHat could close up shop tomorrow for any reason and the switch to another Linux distribution would be fairly painless. I find comfort in that. Now if Microsoft were to close up shop tomorrow there would be many who have built their businesses around Microsoft software in big trouble. I don't think either will happen any time real soon but you never know.



Thanks for the information. But what about this "Star Office" that I've read is the best Linux office suite? Isn't that somehow tied into Sun or Oracle? The other thing I wonder is the privacy and spybot stuff. I'm convinced that Microsoft is not to be trusted in the least, but what about the hackability of my computer if I switch over to Linux, and being monitored, etc.?

I'm sure I live under an illusion right now, and I'm willing to listen to exactly how and why I am. But for the moment, I've got a personal firewall, a virus scan program and a couple different programs (Windows Washer and a shareware thing) that wipe out cookies and other trackers, plus one that searches and ddestroys "spybots."

In the Linux world, are there similar programs that go out and kill all this crap that gets deposited on your computer? Ever since I got these firewalls and "washer" programs, I've been just stunned at how much "detrius" a computer collects after being on the Web for, oh, an hour.

willysnout

  • Member
  • **
  • Posts: 31
  • Kudos: 0
And you wonder why Linux is not Mainstream Like Windows is?
« Reply #16 on: 6 August 2002, 19:54 »
quote:
Originally posted by bazoukas:
if your scanner wont export your Image to PowerPoint and you cant simply take the fucking time to say "HMMMMMMMMMM what if I go via PowerPoint and Insert the scanned image using PowerPoint? After All my boss has assinged to me to do that".

OR when you tell him that "Sir your CDROM has no Conflicts as I showed you. There is no Exlemation Mark on Device Manager. XP sees the CDPLAYER but it cant read shit. That means that the CDPLAYER is messed up." Yet he is MOST SURE that is a Software conflict: I bet my life a software is causing that".  And you tell them "sir there is no way in Hell an Application did that. The driver might have been corrupted but as you see we reinstalled it"



What on earth are you talking about?

quote:
And trust me. If i can do it. EVERYONE can figure out the simple shit. I was a psych major before this (and a Fucking good one at that)



So what sub-set of psych did you major in? Put-Downs 101?

willysnout

  • Member
  • **
  • Posts: 31
  • Kudos: 0
And you wonder why Linux is not Mainstream Like Windows is?
« Reply #17 on: 6 August 2002, 20:09 »
quote:
Originally posted by Calum:
it still seems as if you expect the free software crowd to give the support a company can give. It won't and has no interest in doing so. the free software foundation is a charity, and the many open source developers are hobbyists. However there are many companies, like redhat, mandrake, suse and so on, who will give you any and all the support you need if you buy a licence from them.


I am not a free-rider, and am quite willing to pay for products. I'd really like to see an alternative to Microsoft, which I regard as increasingly anti-consumer. My comments about "the Linux crowd" have been aimed at the "ubertech" mentality that brands non-specialists as idiots.

I think that's got to change. I have specialized knowledge in certain areas. I *sell* this knowledge for a living. And when I sell it, I assure you that I don't do so with arrogance, intended or otherwise. Arrogance is the big danger with specialists.

quote:
The main hurdle when it comes to 'ease of use' is the old chestnut of 'sticking to what you know'. To be frank, if you know how to use windows (or MacOS or whatever) and you now want to use a totally new system, you will have to learn how to do so. It is unrealistic to expect a system to behave in exactly the same way as a different system just to stop people having to learn how to use it. Especially since linux has shitloads more features and abilities than windows which would never be used if it had a windows clone interface.



I hear you. I guess what I'm saying is that, in the quest to run a 3-1/2 minute mile, I need to be sure I can walk to the grocery store. Windows will do that. In my own case, I doubt I'll get too involved with Linux until I know it can do the stuff I am doing now, just as easily and reliably as Windows does.

I know I sound like the MS salesman, but I'm not. All I'm saying is that if I want to write a letter and print it, Windows and Office will do that. I can send e-mails easily with Outlook. I manage my checkbook with Quicken and my taxes with Turbo Tax. I've got a nice little shareware program that displays photos. I've got Virus Scan, Black Ice Defender, Windows Washer and some other stuff for security.

Those are "basics." If that's not available and easily used in Linux, then I won't switch. Which I realize is no skin off your ass, but since this is a forum where people give their views I figured my thought process might be of interest. Most people here seem to have a level of knowledge that's more specialized than mine. What I'm trying to do is inject the perspective of a more typical user.

voidmain

  • VIP
  • Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 5,605
  • Kudos: 184
    • http://voidmain.is-a-geek.net/
And you wonder why Linux is not Mainstream Like Windows is?
« Reply #18 on: 6 August 2002, 20:55 »
quote:
Originally posted by willysnout:

I am not a free-rider, and am quite willing to pay for products. I'd really like to see an alternative to Microsoft, which I regard as increasingly anti-consumer. My comments about "the Linux crowd" have been aimed at the "ubertech" mentality that brands non-specialists as idiots.

I think that's got to change. I have specialized knowledge in certain areas. I *sell* this knowledge for a living. And when I sell it, I assure you that I don't do so with arrogance, intended or otherwise. Arrogance is the big danger with specialists.



Certainly if you are "selling" your knowlege you have to treat the customer with respect if you intend to sell anything. I think you are seeing the few 12 year old "wanna-be Linux gurus because they think it is cool" kids and then believing all Linux lovers/users/programmers are like that. Well, you have those rotten apples on both sides of the fence.  Those 12 year olds are barely out of diapers, let alone any sort of Linux expert (no offense intended to all you 12 year old "wanna-be Linux gurus because they think it is cool" types).  

If you have everything you need and you are happy with it then I would suggest that you stick with what you have (seems like we've come to this conclusion about a month ago).  But if you are interested in checking Linux out and are worried about screwing something up on the install I would suggest getting a copy of that "DemoLinux" CD that some have been talking about here.  I personally have never heard of it or have ever tried it but it sounds like you don't have to install anything.  You just boot it and run it directly from CD and it will not change anything on your hard drive. I'm sure it will not run as fast and there will be several limitations compared to a fully installed Linux distribution but it will give you taste of what you would be up against.

For DemoLinux see: http://www.demolinux.org/

       
quote:

I hear you. I guess what I'm saying is that, in the quest to run a 3-1/2 minute mile, I need to be sure I can walk to the grocery store. Windows will do that. In my own case, I doubt I'll get too involved with Linux until I know it can do the stuff I am doing now, just as easily and reliably as Windows does.



Again, if what you have works for you, stick with it.  If you want to try out Linux without the hassle look for one of those DemoLinux CDs. I believe SuSe has a Live Eval CD that you can download and boot/run from CD as well, you might want to check that out since is it a popular distribution (anyone have any experience or suggestions on a live eval "run from CD" Linux distro?).

     
quote:

I know I sound like the MS salesman, but I'm not. All I'm saying is that if I want to write a letter and print it, Windows and Office will do that. I can send e-mails easily with Outlook. I manage my checkbook with Quicken and my taxes with Turbo Tax. I've got a nice little shareware program that displays photos. I've got Virus Scan, Black Ice Defender, Windows Washer and some other stuff for security.

Those are "basics." If that's not available and easily used in Linux, then I won't switch. Which I realize is no skin off your ass, but since this is a forum where people give their views I figured my thought process might be of interest. Most people here seem to have a level of knowledge that's more specialized than mine. What I'm trying to do is inject the perspective of a more typical user.



There are several Office suites that can do what you want (don't know if they would be up to your specifications but they work for most of us).  I used to use Quicken, there is GNUCash that comes with Linux which is similar.  I use "Tax Cut" for taxes, however it is one of the two programs that I boot up Windows for (it may work under Wine, I've never tried it).  Fortunately I only have to use it once a year. Linux comes with it's own firewall software. You don't need virus software on Linux. In fact all the security tools you really need come with all Linux distributions that I am aware of.

So as you can see, even "I" am not 100% Microsoft free.  There are a couple of applications that I use that the software vendors have not ported to Linux. But those two applications are not written by Microsoft and it is not the fault of Linux that these two companies have not written a version for Linux.  Actually with TaxCut I still do not have to reboot my computer into Windows to run it.  I use a piece of software called "VMware" that allows me to run a copy of Windows "inside" of Linux, and thus run the application I need to run without having to get out of Linux.

But for 99.9% of the things I use a computer for I find that Linux does a far better job. I still need Windows for that 0.1%, hopefully that will change soon. And I certainly don't want to have to purchase Windows XP just to run the newer version of TaxCut. I guess I would go back to paper filing if it came to that. Now, that's me. Your situation might be different.  You might try the DemoLinux and think it's not for you. That's ok too. Use what works for you. I certainly would not want to suggest you go out and install Mandrake, or RedHat, or SuSe, then have you run into all sorts of trouble and get all upset and come back and start jumping all over my case.  I'm not making any profit off of any suggestion or from any Linux distribution so why be subjected to that?  

Also, Sun bought out a company called "Star Division" who originally wrote the office suite "StarOffice".  StarOffice is a very nice office suite and it is *very* much like Microsoft Office and is very compatible with it (and many formats from other office suites).  Now, Sun has released the source code from StarOffice for the open source project OpenOffice.org.  This really doesn't have much to do with GNU/Linux other than you can get a version of the office suite compiled for Linux.  You can also get a Windows version.  

Even if you decide not to use Linux I would suggest that you download the Windows version of OpenOffice from http://www.openoffice.org/ and give it a shot.  I think you will be pleasently surprised.  It will likely do everything that you use Microsoft Office for and with very little learning curve. You can download it for no charge or I believe you can even order a copy on CD if you don't want to download it. And of course you can buy "StarOffice" from http://www.sun.com/ for a fraction of the cost of Microsoft Office and get documentation and support from Sun, and a couple of proprietary/licensed features that are not included with "OpenOffice".

There are several of us who find that Linux does work better for us and we are here to help others who have a totally open mind and are willing to give it a shot, even if it means frustration in the beginning because it is new/different than what they are used to. So like Microsoft's EULA, I certainly won't "guarantee" anything. But what can it hurt giving it an honest try?

[ August 06, 2002: Message edited by: VoidMain ]

Someone please remove this account. Thanks...

pkd_lives

  • Member
  • **
  • Posts: 554
  • Kudos: 0
And you wonder why Linux is not Mainstream Like Windows is?
« Reply #19 on: 6 August 2002, 21:21 »
Willysnout:

You have many questions, many of them answered in this forum time and again. Search around and you will probably find what you need. However some things to start you off down the road.

First off, and without meaning to piss you off, I don't give a rats for anyone not prepared to open their mind and make an effort. Anyone that tied up in themselves is a waste of space, no matter what subject they may specialise in. Now hopefully that has not pissed you off, you see that statement for what it is.

I suggest a little surfing. The office suite you are talking about is Staroffice, and it was purchased by Sun and is now being sold as a viable contender to M$ office. Here is the point. There are many viable contenders to M$ office, including Lotus and Corel, their problem is that .Doc is a proprietary format to M$ and as such they have to reverse engineer the document to convert it, as M$ refuse to publish this format. However openoffice have done a good job, and that was what was sold to Sun. So check out www.openoffice.org Try the package out and see what you think, it's free, it's also NOT staroffice, as Openoffice is still under further development. I like staroffice.

Yes you do pick up detritus surfing, and most of it is from IE. Change your browser, this will make an effect that should please you. There are issues with the different browsers, but you can report your bug to the browser makers, and they will take active steps to cure it, although sometimes it's down to the fact that many websites write to M$ code practice, and not to the world wide web standards.mozilla
opera

I recently converted from Windows, still am slowly, but I am at the stage where my next comp will be 100% Linux compatable, and any software manufacturer that refuses to produce for it will not get my business, and tough on them. I find it far more stable, far more user friendly, it's a different way of thinking, that's all. As for virus and firewall issues, yes there are such products, but they are minor requirements, Linux is more secure by default of it's structure at the basic level. Yes you do need more knowledge, you have to understand what happens in a firewall to configure it properly, otherwise someone else is in control of your system, and you HAVE to trust them, but this is true of windows, it's just that people don't think that way, Linux does not let you off the hook because you're ignorant. You wouldn't walk out on a rainy day without protection, you need to learn to use an umberella, likewise with surfing the net, it seems tricky at first, but you soon realise you were letting your fears get in the way.

My suggestion to you is this. There are alternatives to EVERYTHING M$ make. Try them instead. Send e-mail to Quicken asking for Linux versions. Or get a Mac, Quicken write their software for them. If you really are that scared of Linux use Mac, whilst I have issue with them, they do make a quality product that does successfully compete.

It's down to you, we here hate M$, they have stiffled computer development into a backroad, as we see it, and they have committed attrocities along the way including piracy.

Secondly I believe in open source, I believe no company has the right to release closed source code, I believe that it is against my human rights to freedom, I believe it breaks the American constitution, and I have no way of proving they have never stolen code I may have written.

Maybe this helps.
Tough - Adapt or die : Read The Fucking Manual.

Local Area Network in Australia: the LAN down under.


willysnout

  • Member
  • **
  • Posts: 31
  • Kudos: 0
And you wonder why Linux is not Mainstream Like Windows is?
« Reply #20 on: 6 August 2002, 23:44 »
Voidman and pkd, thanks for the responses. Both of you had some good points in the "debate," and some good practical information. I appreciate it. Two comments and one question, then I'll go away and check out linux over the next several months.

The comment is that I'm not as closed-minded as I might appear. I'm actually getting more open to moving away from Microsoft as a result of the XP fiasco, and their attempts to take over the Internet with this Palladium thing. But I'm also very practical minded, and one facet of this is that I really don't want to be a beta tester science project nor do I want to have to know how to build the car in order to drive it. It's a balancing act, and maybe linux just ain't for me and I'll have to put up and shut up with Microsoft.

The second comment is to Voidman, who noted that some people who are active in that community have a mental age of 12, but that's not a fair description of the whole community. That's an excellent point. Thanks for saying it, and I will try hard to remember it. In my work life I have been close to some very specialized, truly arrogant pricks and therefore am hyper-sensitive to overweening geeks of all kind, comptuer and otherwise. It's a hot button for me because I regard the point of specialized knowledge to be to use those talents for a wider purpose rather than to use your knowledge as an extension of your insecurities. That said, my reaction goes too far as well.


Now for the question: Do you folks have any recommendation for a book on linux for beginners? If not that, maybe some ideas on how to start in the shallow end of the pool? The Linux boards on this site seem to be dominated by arguing techno-nerds. I just want to figure out what it's about and leave the religious wars to others.

Any recommendations would be most appreciated. Thanks much.

voidmain

  • VIP
  • Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 5,605
  • Kudos: 184
    • http://voidmain.is-a-geek.net/
And you wonder why Linux is not Mainstream Like Windows is?
« Reply #21 on: 7 August 2002, 00:04 »
I would suggest that before you spend any money, or buy any books that you download a copy of DemoLinux and just boot it up from your CD.  You may find that it is easier than you think.  In fact, since I recommended it, I am right now in the process of downloading it and checking it out myself and will give you a better assessment of it after I try it out.

Do you have a high speed internet connection and a CD burner?
Someone please remove this account. Thanks...

willysnout

  • Member
  • **
  • Posts: 31
  • Kudos: 0
And you wonder why Linux is not Mainstream Like Windows is?
« Reply #22 on: 7 August 2002, 01:34 »
quote:
Originally posted by VoidMain:
I would suggest that before you spend any money, or buy any books that you download a copy of DemoLinux and just boot it up from your CD.  You may find that it is easier than you think.  In fact, since I recommended it, I am right now in the process of downloading it and checking it out myself and will give you a better assessment of it after I try it out.

Do you have a high speed internet connection and a CD burner?



Yes to the questions. I've been to the site and am thinking about how to download this program. I've got a bunch of other more urgent stuff on the to-do list this week, but maybe I'll try it out next week.

voidmain

  • VIP
  • Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 5,605
  • Kudos: 184
    • http://voidmain.is-a-geek.net/
And you wonder why Linux is not Mainstream Like Windows is?
« Reply #23 on: 7 August 2002, 02:01 »
Well here is the one I am downloading now:

ftp://ftp.fsn.hu/pub/CDROM-Images/demolinux/3.0/demolinux-3.01.iso

I've only got about 25% of it downloaded right now, it seems to be a slow link for me as I am only getting between 10 and 60KB/s. Now it is a very large file (~650MB) so it will take a couple of hours even over a high speed connection.  I would suggest when you are finished using your computer for the evening, you start it downloading and it should be there for you the next morning.

It is a CD ISO image (a standard CD image format).  Any CD burning software should be able to create a CD from this file but you will have to look in your help or manual for your CD software to determine the proper way for that particular software to write an ISO file to CD. You can not just copy it to the CD as that will not work.

I should have my CD burned and tested some time this evening.  I will let you know if I think it is worth your trouble.

[ August 06, 2002: Message edited by: VoidMain ]

Someone please remove this account. Thanks...

choasforages

  • VIP
  • Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 1,729
  • Kudos: 7
    • http://it died
And you wonder why Linux is not Mainstream Like Windows is?
« Reply #24 on: 7 August 2002, 03:00 »
ahhh, demo linux, i have had both good and bad experiances with it. first it doesn't like my dads thinkpad 1400. but i used it to save my friends winxp computer. so if it doesn't work like promised don't give up hope immediabn'ly. and as for my job, im getting ready to recommend a copy of winnt 4.0 for a guy that needs to upgrade the os on his laptop. suprise, linux isn't an answer unfourtantly. he already knows howto use windows, its not going to change, and im giong to get paid for it, though i will try to show him apps like openoffice and mozilla. im pushing for them to decide on a new macintosh though. well, have phun
x86: a hack on a hack of a hackway
alpha, hewlett packed it A-way
ppc: the fruity way
mips: the graphical way
sparc: the sunny way
4:20.....forget the DMCA for a while!!!

willysnout

  • Member
  • **
  • Posts: 31
  • Kudos: 0
And you wonder why Linux is not Mainstream Like Windows is?
« Reply #25 on: 7 August 2002, 05:10 »
quote:
Originally posted by VoidMain:
I should have my CD burned and tested some time this evening.  I will let you know if I think it is worth your trouble.


Thanks. I don't know if this will be informative, but I have Roxio "Easy CD Creator 5 Platinum" for burning CDs.

choasforages

  • VIP
  • Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 1,729
  • Kudos: 7
    • http://it died
And you wonder why Linux is not Mainstream Like Windows is?
« Reply #26 on: 7 August 2002, 05:17 »
hmmm, as long as it has a make disc from image option, or something like that. thats how my dads cd software works. it should work. ill have to see if anyone i know knows how to burn a .iso file with the cd software you have. and for specializing in a perticiular area, not to be too nosy, but what exactly do you do. i have always been curious. and if you want to know, i am a junior at high school/*other wise known as elenthgrade*/
x86: a hack on a hack of a hackway
alpha, hewlett packed it A-way
ppc: the fruity way
mips: the graphical way
sparc: the sunny way
4:20.....forget the DMCA for a while!!!

voidmain

  • VIP
  • Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 5,605
  • Kudos: 184
    • http://voidmain.is-a-geek.net/
And you wonder why Linux is not Mainstream Like Windows is?
« Reply #27 on: 7 August 2002, 05:24 »
Well, here are some instructions on linuxiso.com that have a section for "Easy CD Creator":

http://www.linuxiso.org/viewdoc.php/winoncdrwin.html

Hopefully the instructions match up with the version you have...
Someone please remove this account. Thanks...

voidmain

  • VIP
  • Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 5,605
  • Kudos: 184
    • http://voidmain.is-a-geek.net/
And you wonder why Linux is not Mainstream Like Windows is?
« Reply #28 on: 7 August 2002, 05:27 »
quote:
Originally posted by choasforages:
/*other wise known as elenthgrade*/


elenthgrade?  I think I missed that one. Or was that the one right before twethgrade?      Hey, did you happen to check your PMs?  You asked for something in another thread...

[ August 06, 2002: Message edited by: VoidMain ]

Someone please remove this account. Thanks...

Bazoukas

  • Member
  • **
  • Posts: 866
  • Kudos: 140
    • http://whitehouse.com
And you wonder why Linux is not Mainstream Like Windows is?
« Reply #29 on: 7 August 2002, 11:12 »
quote:
Originally posted by willysnout:


So what sub-set of psych did you major in? Put-Downs 101?



 And your problem is?

  Read my whole post  and try to get my point. I think you are too sensitive for your own good.
 

   I used a real life example (that happened to me) of morons not wanting to learn even the Basics "How to install a driver" and so on.
 

  And no it was Cognitive psychology. And two courses were on Ph.D ( offered to me by my Teacher)level while i was a Sophmore.
You asked. Dont feel sorry that you did.

Edit: i edited this post three times after I saw that whats his name is not bad afterall.

[ August 07, 2002: Message edited by: bazoukas ]

Yeah