I wouldn't like it, but it still wouldn't meet the criteria for binning. So I wouldn't bin it, but that certainly wouldn't refrain from giving the poster a good verbal thrashing.
If you don't like bitch threads, then go ahead and tell Bedouin you want a rule against them. As for me, to answer your question in the other thread, the reason for my flip-flop is because no one seems to be able to make up their minds on which threads should and should not be binned. Time and again I have been labelled either too lax or too authoritarian. So all I am doing now is toe the party line.
I'm not sure what you're asking exactly. Meet the criteria to be binned? No.
You said you would unbin any thread that doesn't meet the criteria. So should it be unbinned?