Stop Microsoft

All Things Microsoft => Microsoft as a Company => Topic started by: new2linux55 on 12 May 2003, 16:29

Title: Is the end near for Microsoft?
Post by: new2linux55 on 12 May 2003, 16:29
Seems Microsoft has just landed them a massive fine!

http://www.theregister.co.uk/content/6/30620.html (http://www.theregister.co.uk/content/6/30620.html)
Title: Is the end near for Microsoft ?
Post by: Faust on 12 May 2003, 16:32
2.2 TRILLION!

Holy shit, If the judge actually orders that the full amount be paid then they are screwed, not even they can afford that.  (http://smile.gif)

But I doubt they will ask for the full amount.   :(
Title: Is the end near for Microsoft ?
Post by: TheKnifeThrower on 12 May 2003, 20:19
I hope that judge imposes the full fine. Otherwise we might have to kill him.
Title: Is the end near for Microsoft ?
Post by: baggab on 13 May 2003, 00:00
M$ always seems to weasle out of these things!

I am happy to hear they are in trouble -- somebody throw them a boat anchor!
Title: Is the end near for Microsoft ?
Post by: Win on 13 May 2003, 10:22
we only jus beg un
Title: Is the end near for Microsoft ?
Post by: lazygamer on 13 May 2003, 12:32
/cheers loudly

Never imagined this could happen(powerful lawsuit that is).

Even if the full amount is not payed, it could still be a very damaging amount they "plea bargain" for.

Question is, will MS suddenly start making Wind0ze far more secure?

What would be extra useful though, is a big media circus about this. Get people doubting MS, than get moronic "security experts" creating hysteria about hackers being able to hack your Windows box and steal your credit card info etc(which is hardly farfetched, but in principle it's still media BS).

 
quote:
The Federal Trade Commission last year demanded that Microsoft improve its Passport security or face stiff fines of up to $11,000 per violation. Redmond promised to work harder to protect consumer information and launched it's Trustworthy Computing initiative to put regulators' minds at ease.

Well, the FTC is looking into the Passport breach and could slap Microsoft with a fine of $2.2 trillion to cover all 200 million violated users.

"If we were to find that they didn't take reasonable safeguards to protect the information, that could be an order violation," Jessica Rich, assistant director for financial practices at the FTC, told the AP.


So not only have they been warned, but they are being charged with screwing over 200 million users!!! Ok even if they weasel out, MS is up against some big odds here, something's gotta happen.

Ok but I'm worried about this "reasonable safeguards" thing. This could be their weasel area.
Title: Is the end near for Microsoft ?
Post by: jtpenrod on 13 May 2003, 13:01
quote:
Question is, will MS suddenly start making Wind0ze far more secure?
There's so much kludgy code in there already that "suddenly" making it secure will not be possible. They have made some progress in this area lately, however, this hasn't been the first security breech of the Passport system. They still have one helluva long road ahead of them to make Winderz as secure as Linux.
quote:
So not only have they been warned, but they are being charged with screwing over 200 million users!!! Ok even if they weasel out, MS is up against some big odds here, something's gotta happen.

Ok but I'm worried about this "reasonable safeguards" thing. This could be their weasel area.
You can be sure that His Gatesness' legal eagles will play up the "reasonable safeguards" thing for all it's worth. There will for sure be bad publicity over this. And it could very well take considerable luster off the whole .NET (or whatever the hell they're calling it this week) scam... er... scheme. OTOH, I could see this as being a springboard into Palladium (or whatever the hell they're calling it this week). They may very well use this as an excuse to get laws passed that mandate "Fritz chips" and the rest of it that locks out all non-M$ apps.  :mad:   Let's hope to hell that doesn't happen.

Of course, judging from their performance in court during the anti-trust trial, there's an even better possibility that they'll pull some more bone-headed stunts in court and really piss off the judge. As an extra bonus, we may get to see Steve "Monkey-Boy" Ballmer saying more foolish things.   :D  
______________________________________
Live Free or Die: Linux
(http://www.otakupc.com/etsig/dolphin.gif)
"There: now you'll never have to look at those dirty Windows anymore"
      --Daffy Duck
Title: Is the end near for Microsoft ?
Post by: Calum on 13 May 2003, 14:57
quote:
So not only have they been warned, but they are being charged with screwing over 200 million users!!! Ok even if they weasel out, MS is up against some big odds here, something's gotta happen.

bollocks!
you just watch the sheep, it'll be "oh woe, save us mr gates! we must use windows but now the mean nasty judge has told us it is not safe! you must make it safe for us so we need never fear that our computers might be compromised by those filthy long haired hackers ever again!"

how likely do you think it is that the sheep will accept an OS made from the ground up by these filthy long haired hackers their culture has brought them up to despise?

remember it is a minority who think for themselves.
Title: Is the end near for Microsoft ?
Post by: Zombie9920 on 13 May 2003, 21:07
This is completely false. The Register has a habit of reporting stuff like a tabloid would. They took the $11,000 per incident fine and took the number of accounts(200 million) and multiplied the numbers together. There is no basis to this story other than some fool making assumptions and stories up.
Title: Is the end near for Microsoft ?
Post by: Faust on 13 May 2003, 21:33
Actually there is a fairly large basis for that story.  Mainly that an inanely stupid fuck up from Microsoft was discovered in less that half an hour by a single computer security advisor.  And that this flaw compromised the security details of an extremely large number of people.  I do agree that the numbers are exagerated though.  (http://smile.gif)
Title: Is the end near for Microsoft ?
Post by: Calum on 13 May 2003, 21:38
that sounds more likely, of course technically this should still add up to the same amount, but in all likelihood it won't. Just like life imprisonment means a few years, while the person you murdered is still dead when you are finishing up your sentence.

Do you have a link to a better article about this situation, zombie? i am all in favour of seeing things from a few perspectives.
Title: Is the end near for Microsoft ?
Post by: baggab on 14 May 2003, 00:50
I may be that the fines are inflated or that they will never be enforced.

But here's a new one from the Wall Street Journal.  Electronic Arts, #1 game designer, is going with Sony exclusively.  I'm sure Bill's pissed about that loss, in a 27 billion dollar market.

Follow the money!

[ May 13, 2003: Message edited by: baggab ]

Title: Is the end near for Microsoft ?
Post by: mc0282 on 14 May 2003, 06:49
i am going to cry, is my dream coming true ? is microsoft could be out of business ?  if these judge fine microsoft i am going to send him  lovely letter to him for his good ass work...

Question thou make me wonder if these virus being poping out , couldn't microsoft had something to do with it ? they lunch virus and blame on hackers so the way make easy for them to unleashed the Trust Computing whatever they call it shit ?

[ May 13, 2003: Message edited by: mc0282 ]

Title: Is the end near for Microsoft ?
Post by: LordWiccara on 14 May 2003, 07:20
hahahhaha sucks to be microsoft.  thats what they get for supplying us with SHIT
Title: Is the end near for Microsoft ?
Post by: NM on 14 May 2003, 11:21
You are aware that politicans can be bought and sold?
Group that would have to prosecute here would be the AG's office, Mr. Ashcroft, I presume. . . .
Title: Is the end near for Microsoft ?
Post by: Calum on 14 May 2003, 13:59
quote:
Originally posted by mc0282:
i am going to cry, is my dream coming true ? is microsoft could be out of business ?  if these judge fine microsoft i am going to send him  lovely letter to him for his good ass work...
it's not going to happen. Last year when Ansett went bust (in Australia) everybody said "Oh no, now Qantas is a monopoly and can charge what they like as their only competition no longer exists". In response the Australian government spent a shitload of taxpayers' money on subsidising Ansett so there would be some competition in the business. is that fair? no. I was dead set against it, although i think quite a lot of Australians (a majority? who knows?) were in favour of it.

This is not the same situation however if Microsoft goes bust overnight (like if they were fined and had to file for bankruptcy as a result) everybody would be going "Oh no!" our critical systems require microsoft's support, our economy and national security is at stake" and what with all this high fear terrorism shit that the USA's government is churning out right now, those security fears will be acute, and the government would simply pour money into microsoft in the "public interest" or some such bullshit, and the public would support that.

To get rid of microsoft properly they need to be publicly shown to be incompetent and overpriced. there will be no quick death for microsoft for this very reason.

 
quote:
Question thou make me wonder if these virus being poping out , couldn't microsoft had something to do with it ? they lunch virus and blame on hackers so the way make easy for them to unleashed the Trust Computing whatever they call it shit ?



possible, but highly unlikely in my opinion - with all these viruses around a lot of people are making a big noise about "windows is not secure" but most of them are not saying "palladium is the answer" - they are usually saying "solaris/BSD/linux is the answer", so microsoft would be doing themselves out of business by helping viruses to circulate (in fact by having such an insecure OS, this is exactly what they are doing, although in an indirect way). Also, think of the stink if it were to be made public that microsoft were doing this? no i think they would steer well clear of it.
Title: Is the end near for Microsoft ?
Post by: Faust on 14 May 2003, 15:54
quote:
it's not going to happen. Last year when Ansett went bust (in Australia) everybody said "Oh no, now Qantas is a monopoly and can charge what they like as their only competition no longer exists". In response the Australian government spent a shitload of taxpayers' money on subsidising Ansett so there would be some competition in the business. is that fair? no. I was dead set against it, although i think quite a lot of Australians (a majority? who knows?) were in favour of it.


Which did absolutely nothing anyway.  Lew and Fox decided to buy Ansett but pulled out at the last minute.  Now we have wasted thousands (millions?) of  tax payer dollars for nothing.  It would have been better to spend the money on workers entitlements and then to let Ansett die.

Anyway for domestic flights we have REx in competition with Qantas - they have bought up a lot of the old Ansett planes including all of Kendell.   (http://smile.gif)   Those New Zealanders will never be competition to our mighty Qantas!  Muah ha ha ha!  

And I think the money MS would need to keep running even a quarter of their business would be too much for even Bush to explain away.  A huge fine may not kill them but it would at least cripple them... err... cripple them more that is.   (http://smile.gif)  

edit:spelling

[ May 14, 2003: Message edited by: Faust ]

Title: Is the end near for Microsoft ?
Post by: lazygamer on 14 May 2003, 16:34
quote:
Originally posted by Zombie9920:
This is completely false. The Register has a habit of reporting stuff like a tabloid would. They took the $11,000 per incident fine and took the number of accounts(200 million) and multiplied the numbers together. There is no basis to this story other than some fool making assumptions and stories up.


This is strange, I am a big Register fan. Ever since I started seeing some of the Reg articles, I made the register my broswer homepage. Does this have anything to do with the fact that The Register is blatantly anti-microsoft, and you happen not to like that? How about you show me some anti-register sites eh?


Calum:Sigh, your probably right, No quick death fix. What's really scary though, is the idea that the US government would bail out Microsoft!
Title: Is the end near for Microsoft ?
Post by: SAJChurchey on 14 May 2003, 20:09
Awesome, even this will put a small dent in Billy G's wallet.

As a friend of mine once said,

 
quote:

M$'s days are numbered...it may be a big number, but they're numbered nonetheless.

Title: Is the end near for Microsoft ?
Post by: ShawnD1 on 14 May 2003, 23:30
quote:
The flaw was discovered close to four minutes after security researcher Muhammad Faisal Rauf Danka set to work on Passport. He was able to access Passport accounts at will by typing "emailpwdreset" into a URL that has the e-mail address of a user account and the address where a reset message can be sent.


oh my god.... 4 minutes? maybe microsoft should hire some 15 year olds to check for security flaws.
Title: Is the end near for Microsoft ?
Post by: Faust on 15 May 2003, 21:03
This is probably why Microsoft would pay security consultants by the hour and not for each bug found.  ;)
Title: Is the end near for Microsoft ?
Post by: Calum on 15 May 2003, 14:08
here's another reason why microsoft might not be about to be put out of business by the government any time soon:
opensecrets.org (sadly a fucking ASP page!) (http://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/summary.asp?ID=D000000115&Name=Microsoft+Corp)
Title: Is the end near for Microsoft ?
Post by: Faust on 15 May 2003, 17:06
Man the "campaign contribution" thing sucks.
Title: Is the end near for Microsoft ?
Post by: new2linux55 on 24 May 2003, 14:53
Someone should have told them never put all youre eggs in the one basket.